Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Review

Red Dead Redemption’s Nintendo Switch port, released on August 17, 2023, included the 2010 game and its Undead Nightmare zombie expansion. It was a solid port developed by Double Eleven, running at 30fps with 720p docked and 540p handheld resolutions, featuring minor pop-in but sharp textures and smooth horseback riding. For a portable console, it really didn’t get any better, and it seemed that was the end of the road for Red Dead Redemption.

That changed when anyone who owned it on Switch received a free Switch 2 upgrade in December 2025, which boosted performance to 60fps, added DLSS, and enhanced the skies. Join ex-outlaw John Marston on an epic journey to hunt down his former gang across the waning American frontier and into Mexico, all in a bid to earn a federal pardon after his family is taken hostage. 

Relive the betrayal that leads to violent redemption as civilization closes in. This seventh-gen cinematic open-world saga delivers gripping storytelling, precise gunplay, and an immersive world of dusty trails and moral dilemmas, with the Switch 2 version standing out for its convenient portability, making it ideal for quick dives into its haunting Western tale. Has the weakest port of Red Dead been redeemed? Find out in our Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch 2 Edition review!

Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch 2 Edition
Developer: Rockstar Games, Double Eleven
Publisher: Rockstar Games
Platforms: Windows PC, Android, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Nintendo Switch 2 (reviewed)
Release Date: May 18, 2010 / August 17, 2023 / December 2, 2025 (Nintendo Switch 2 Edition)
Price: $49.99

By now, everyone should know Red Dead Redemption‘s story: U.S. agents hold ex-outlaw John Marston’s family hostage, compelling him to hunt and kill old gangmates Bill Williamson, Javier Escuella, and leader Dutch van der Linde across the dying American frontier and Mexico for a pardon. The wild west fades as trains, cars, and machine guns tame the frontier.

John’s journey from the lawless New Austin to the bustling streets of Blackwater reflects the decline of outlaws. Chasing his gang for a pardon, he sacrifices himself for his family, yet can’t escape his past, with the title bitterly mocking such hope. Betrayals within the gang lead to bloodshed, and John’s death sets Jack on a vengeful outlaw path, continuing the cycle of violence.

Side characters bring the fading West to life, adding depth to its story, underscoring ironic redemption, with elements of magical realism and dark humor. A sharp takedown of the romanticized Western myth, laced with cynicism and sly, sardonic wit, delivers an unmistakable sense of looming doom. It’s still one of the better pieces of Western media and stayed prescient thanks to its impeccable script, atmosphere, and gameplay. 

Red Dead Redemption’s open world blends its themes of freedom and solitude with the fading colors of a wild frontier. Every trail invites exploration, and each horizon carries the promise of adventure or the threat of danger.

Golden light spills across rolling plains, dense forests, and rugged mountains, casting long shadows over the land. Players can wander freely, whether on horseback or on foot, feeling the wind whip across John’s weathered face as the dust of the past swirls around him. The world is teeming with movement, wildlife darting through the brush, livestock grazing on hillsides with danger lurking, from stealthy cougars to wolves prowling in packs, ready to strike at the unwary.

Marston is a veritable Marlboro Man, and New Austin is flavor country. Despite its age, this is still one of the most convincing and detailed depictions of the historical American Southwest. It’s a home where the buffalo roam, and even at its most bleak, there is no denying the untamed beauty that Rockstar’s boys captured. 

Regretfully, the online multiplayer is still not present. Like in the initial release on Switch, Undead Nightmare is included, turning the frontier into a zombie apocalypse. In this alternate take, John must survive relentless undead hordes while using ammunition as currency. This playful twist on Red Dead Redemption’s core systems stands out as a highlight, especially with the loss of multiplayer.

Though shorter, it’s filled with the same attention to detail and charming period banter. Players will face plenty of ‘back-against-the-wall’ moments, fending off waves of zombies in familiar locations. While the game once pushed seventh-gen hardware to its limits, the Switch port impresses by keeping a steady frame rate and handling massive zombie swarms without breaking a sweat.

Red Dead Redemption maintains the appearance of a polished seventh-gen game, which is entirely fitting because it is one. However, one aspect that has always held it back, even when it was cutting-edge, is its playability. The gunplay and cover mechanics weren’t always dependable. John moved sluggishly, lacking urgency, almost as if he were wearing lead boots. His animations are excessively drawn out, and canned animations take too long. 

I am happy to report that the higher frame rate on Switch 2 improves Red Dead Redemption‘s playability. John feels more responsive now. The added fluidity makes everything feel snappier and more urgent now, like John moves with a purpose. The mouse mode is especially twitchy and makes landing crackshots off the broadside of a steer’s ass much easier. 

The priority placed on animation for the sake of realism can make Red Dead Redemption a bit tedious to play. The dead-eye mechanic ends up feeling like a crutch to compensate for the absence of a skill ceiling, given that John is rooted in weighty physics and incapable of the absurd feats seen in games like Saints Row or Crackdown.

It’s plain as day why Red Dead Redemption became a classic on seventh-gen consoles. Its weathered characters and skillfully written script are among the best of its era. It stands as a technological marvel with impeccable attention to detail.

While the sluggish gameplay and unresponsive controls have always been a point of debate, with the right mindset, it’s possible to adapt to them. It’s worth getting used to them because Red Dead Redemption is truly more than the sum of its parts.

Probably the best thing about the Switch 2 Edition is that it’s a free upgrade, a remarkably generous gesture of goodwill in an era of rampant corporate greed. With all of its flourishes and exceptional polish on Switch 2, at its core, you’re getting one of the better open-world adventure games that veers into being a full-on life sim with RPG elements. It’ll be interesting to see if the inevitable port of the sequel maintains the same level of quality.

Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch 2 Edition was reviewed on Nintendo Switch 2 using a code provided by Rockstar Games. Additional information about Niche Gamer’s review/ethics policy is here. Red Dead Redemption is now available for Windows PC (via Steam), Android, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Nintendo Switch 2, Xbox 360, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X|S.

, , ,

The Verdict: 9

The Good

  • Impressive lighting effects and attention to detail with beautiful vistas and immersive side activities
  • Sharply written dialogue and good story
  • The filthy and rugged frontier ambiance
  • A technical marvel and runs 60 frames per second confidently on Nintendo Switch 2 plus mouse mode support
  • Undead Nightmare is a blast and offers a fun twist on the core Red Dead Redemption experience

The Bad

  • Suddenly getting mauled by a wild cougar while in the middle of a shootout with bandits
  • The online modes are still gutted

About

A youth destined for damnation.


Where'd our comments go? Subscribe to become a member to get commenting access and true free speech!